Skip to content
NEWThe bicycle accident calculator is live Already have an offer? Check it →
Free decision tool · 90 seconds

Should you accept that settlement offer?

Enter the offer you received and a few details about your case. The tool compares the offer with comparable settlements and tells you whether to accept, counter or wait, and it shows the verdict without asking for an email.

Offer evaluator · 6 steps FREE · NO SIGNUP
Step 1 of 6 The current offer

The current offer

The offer is the number the tool compares with the fair range it calculates at the end.

$
Is this the first offer?
Yes
No
Not sure
A first offer is typically 30 to 50% of what the case eventually settles for.
Who made the offer?
At-fault driver's insurer
Your own insurer (UM/PIP)
Company / business adjuster
Not sure
Have you been asked to sign a release?
Yes
No
Not sure
A signed release ends the case in almost every situation, which changes the recommendation if your treatment is not complete.
$
Enter the at-fault driver's policy limit if you know it. Because most cases settle at or below the policy limit whatever the fair value is, the estimate is capped at that limit. Leave the field blank if you do not know it.

The accident

The typical settlement range depends on the type of accident and on the state where it happened, which alone explains roughly half of the variation across cases.

What type of accident caused your injury?
Car accident
Truck / 18-wheeler
Motorcycle
Bicycle
Pedestrian
Uber / Lyft
Slip and fall
Other / Dog bite
Cases in plaintiff-friendly states (CA, NY, IL, FL, NJ) tend to settle higher, while cases in contributory negligence states (AL, MD, NC, VA, DC) tend to settle lower. The state can move the fair range by 30 to 40% in either direction.

Economic damages

Economic damages are the dollar costs of the accident, and every settlement calculation starts from them. Enter the amounts you know and leave the rest blank.

Medical bills so farER, hospital, doctor visits, PT, imaging
$
Estimated future medical careOngoing treatment, future surgery, long-term PT
$
Lost wages so farDays/weeks you couldn't work
$
Future lost income / reduced earning abilityPermanent impact on your work capacity
$
Property damageVehicle, bike, phone, clothing damaged in accident
$
▶ Economic damages running total $0

Injury severity

The value of pain and suffering in your case depends on how severe the injuries are. Describe them as they are, because an overstated injury makes the estimate less accurate.

What best describes your primary injury?
Soft tissue / sprain
Fracture / broken bone
Surgery required
Traumatic brain injury
Spinal injury
Permanent impairment
Wrongful death
Did you go to the ER?
Yes
No
Were you hospitalized?
No
1-2 days
3-7 days
7+ days
Surgery status
No surgery
Yes, had surgery
Recommended
Symptom status
Fully recovered
Improving
Still treating
Permanent symptoms

Pain and suffering factors

Non-economic damages reflect how the injury affected your daily life. Each factor below adjusts the pain and suffering multiplier, and a documented effect raises the estimate.

Treatment duration
Under 4 weeks
1-6 months
6+ months
Impact on daily life (work, sleep, mobility, family)
Minimal
Moderate
Severe
Pain duration
Resolved
Months
Ongoing / chronic
Visible scarring or disfigurement
No
Yes
Documented emotional distress, PTSD, anxiety
No / not documented
Yes, documented

Liability and evidence

The estimate depends heavily on the strength of the evidence and on your share of fault, because most states reduce a settlement in proportion to that share.

Who appears to be at fault?
Other party (mostly)
Shared fault
Me (mostly)
Unsure
What percentage of fault may be assigned to you?
Your share of fault 0%
0%25%50%75%100%
Most states follow comparative negligence, which reduces your settlement by your percentage of fault, and most of those states allow no recovery once your share reaches 50% or 51%. The contributory negligence states (AL, MD, NC, VA, DC) allow no recovery if you are at fault at all.
Is liability disputed?
No
Yes
Not sure
Police report or incident report filed?
Yes
No
Evidence strength (witnesses, photos, video, dashcam)
Strong
Some
Weak
None
Was the at-fault party DUI, fleeing, or grossly negligent?
No
Yes
Not sure
A DUI, a hit-and-run, excessive speed or gross negligence can substantially increase the settlement value, because the at-fault party is exposed to punitive damages. The increase is typically a multiplier of 1.5x to 2x on the base settlement.
Your verdict
FAIR OFFER
Your offer on the value scale
Too low Below Negotiable Fair Strong
Your offer
$0
Fair range
$0 to $0
Estimated value
$0
Offer gap from fair midpoint 0%
What to do next

Loading…

Inputs summary will appear here.

This estimate is based on a comparable claim valuation method and is not legal advice.

How the verdict is built

A number built from your own damages.

A published formula

The verdict builds a fair value from your medical costs, lost wages and injuries, then adjusts it for your accident type, your state and your share of fault, with every figure on the methodology page.

MMI-aware

If you have not finished treatment, the tool says so, because settling before maximum medical improvement (MMI) is the single most costly timing mistake.

Private by default

Your inputs stay in your browser, and the full verdict appears without an email address.

The 5 verdict tiers, explained

The recommended action depends on where your offer falls against the median settlement for comparable cases. The table shows the same five tiers the tool uses.

Offer as % of median Verdict tier What to do
Below 50% LOWBALL Do not sign. Counter with a written demand, and consider an attorney if the case is serious.
50 to 75% BELOW MARKET Counter near the median and cite comparable settlement data.
75 to 90% NEGOTIABLE Counter at the median, because the insurance company usually has room to move up.
90 to 115% FAIR Accept, or make a modest counter. Accepting is defensible if liability is clear and you are past MMI.
Above 115% STRONG / ABOVE MARKET Accept, because further negotiation rarely adds a meaningful amount.

How to decide in 5 steps

These five steps follow the framework personal injury attorneys use to review an offer, reduced to what you can do yourself in 30 minutes.

  1. Calculate the typical settlement range for your case. The tool above gives the low, median and high settlements for your accident type, severity and treatment status, and every later decision is guesswork without that range.
  2. Compare your offer with the median instead of with your gut feeling. Divide the offer by the median. A result below 90% is below market, a result within 90 to 115% is fair and a result above 115% is strong.
  3. Match your verdict tier to its recommended action. A lowball calls for a firm written counter, a below-market offer for a counter at the median, a fair offer for acceptance or a modest counter and a strong offer for acceptance.
  4. Check your state's filing deadline before you decide. Most states give 2 to 4 years from the accident date, and you have less leverage if the deadline is within 90 days. The filing deadline tool shows the deadline for your state.
  5. Put the decision in writing instead of giving it by phone. Counter by email with a specific number and a reference to comparable settlement data, and keep the tone professional and unemotional.
Why your first offer is almost always low

According to industry data, the typical first offer from major insurance companies (Geico, State Farm, Allstate, Progressive, USAA) is 30 to 50% of what the case eventually settles for. Roughly 40 to 50% of unrepresented claimants accept the first offer, and they typically receive 60 to 70% less than those who counter. A first offer is a starting position that is designed to anchor the negotiation low.

What you give up when you accept

When you accept an offer, you sign a settlement release, which is a full and final resolution of the claim. A worse condition or a surgery you did not expect does not reopen the claim. A court can set a release aside only in narrow cases, such as fraud, duress or misrepresentation of material facts, and you would have to prove them. Read every word of the release before you sign, ideally with a lawyer reviewing the language.

Sample counter-offer template

A written counter states a specific number in a professional tone, without emotion, and cites comparable settlement data. The first version below is a blank template and the second is a filled example.

▷ Blank template (fill in your numbers)

Thank you for your offer of $[number]. Based on comparable settlements for [type of incident] with [injury type] in [state], the typical range is $[low] to $[high]. I am requesting a revised figure of $[counter] to reflect the documented medical expenses, lost income, and pain and suffering associated with this claim.

▷ Filled example (Texas auto, herniated disc)

Thank you for your offer of $12,000. Based on comparable settlements for auto accident cases with herniated disc injuries in Texas, the typical range is $22,000 to $75,000. I am requesting a revised figure of $41,000 to reflect the documented medical expenses, lost income, and pain and suffering associated with this claim.

How adjusters pressure you, and how to respond

Each of these statements is a pressure tactic that compresses your timeline and lowers what the insurance company pays.

What they say
"This offer expires Friday."
Your move
The offer lapses if the deadline passes, but the adjuster can usually extend it or make the same offer again, which is why a short deadline is usually a pressure tactic. Say thisI appreciate the proposal and will respond by [date 14 to 21 days out]. Please confirm it remains available through that date. Many adjusters will confirm.
What they say
"I'm not authorized to go higher."
Your move
An adjuster has a band of settlement authority, and the first offer is rarely at the top of it. Say thisI understand. Could you escalate this to your supervisor? The amount is below comparable settlements for similar cases. Most adjusters will escalate.
What they say
"You should accept before your treatment is finished."
Your move
This is the most financially damaging tactic, because settling before MMI typically reduces the settlement by 30 to 50%. Say thisI'd prefer to wait until I've reached maximum medical improvement so my treatment costs are fully known. I'll reach back out when my doctor confirms it.
What they say
"If you don't accept, we may have to deny the claim."
Your move
An insurance company needs real grounds to deny a claim. Most states have unfair claims settlement practices laws, based on a national model act, which treat a refusal to pay a claim without a reasonable investigation as an unfair practice. Say thisI'd like clarification on the grounds for any potential denial, separate from settlement talks. Document the statement and report it to your state's department of insurance. In many states you cannot sue the other driver's insurance company directly for bad faith, which makes the complaint the main remedy.

Questions about the verdict

How accurate is this estimate?

The estimate is a benchmark and does not replace an appraisal of your case. The range comes from a published formula built on your medical costs, lost wages, injury type and severity, while your actual outcome depends on liability, jurisdiction and documentation. The estimate is a sanity check on the offer, and it does not guarantee a result.

Why does it tell me to wait if I haven't reached MMI?

The tool tells you to wait because settling before maximum medical improvement (MMI) means accepting money before your final medical costs are known. Settling early is the most expensive timing mistake people make, and it typically reduces the settlement by 30 to 50%. The tool flags it whatever the offer is.

Do I have to enter an email to see my result?

You do not have to enter an email to see your result. The verdict and the full range appear on the screen immediately. You can choose to have the detailed report emailed to you, but the tool never requires it.

Should I accept the first settlement offer?

You should almost never accept the first settlement offer. The first offer from major insurance companies is typically 30 to 50% of what the case eventually settles for. About 40 to 50% of unrepresented claimants accept the first offer, and they typically receive 60 to 70% less than those who counter. The timing guide explains how long to wait.

What is considered a fair settlement offer?

A fair settlement offer is one within 90 to 115% of the median settlement for comparable cases, which means the same accident type, similar severity and your state. An offer below 90% is below market and worth countering, while an offer above 115% is strong and worth accepting.

How long do I have to decide on a settlement offer?

Most settlement offers have no strict expiration, but adjusters typically expect a response within 14 to 30 days. An offer that states a deadline lapses when the deadline passes, although the adjuster can usually extend it. The bigger deadline is your state's statute of limitations for filing a lawsuit, which is typically 2 to 4 years from the accident. The filing deadline tool shows the deadline for your state.

Can I negotiate after I receive an offer?

You can negotiate after you receive an offer, and negotiation is the norm. Personal injury attorneys counter virtually every first offer as a matter of routine. The second offer is usually 50 to 150% higher than the first.

Is this legal advice?

This tool does not give legal advice. SettlementValueCalculator.com is an informational tool and is not a law firm, and the verdict is general guidance that is not legal advice for your specific case. For a binding opinion, talk to a licensed attorney, many of whom offer a free consultation.

If the verdict says counter or wait, a licensed personal injury attorney in your state can review the offer and your timing, and many offer a free first consultation. SettlementValueCalculator.com is not a law firm.

Do I need a lawyer? →