The 5 verdict tiers, explained
The recommended action depends on where your offer falls against the median settlement for comparable cases. The table shows the same five tiers the tool uses.
| Offer as % of median | Verdict tier | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Below 50% | LOWBALL | Do not sign. Counter with a written demand, and consider an attorney if the case is serious. |
| 50 to 75% | BELOW MARKET | Counter near the median and cite comparable settlement data. |
| 75 to 90% | NEGOTIABLE | Counter at the median, because the insurance company usually has room to move up. |
| 90 to 115% | FAIR | Accept, or make a modest counter. Accepting is defensible if liability is clear and you are past MMI. |
| Above 115% | STRONG / ABOVE MARKET | Accept, because further negotiation rarely adds a meaningful amount. |